Glottochronology proposes to date language splits arithmetically
node
Morris Swadesh set out a method for converting the proportion of shared cognates in a fixed list of basic meanings into elapsed time since two languages diverged, assuming a universal replacement rate calibrated on documented histories. The proposal was attacked immediately and comprehensively: rates are not constant across meanings, languages or historical circumstances, and the cognacy judgements the arithmetic consumes are themselves the contested output of comparative work. Mainstream historical linguistics had largely abandoned the method by the 1970s.
A node is not a place. Drawing it on a map would assert something about the world that no stored fact supports.
Read in · 1
Timeline
No dated observations are stored for this object. Atlas shows what was observed and when — it does not infer a history.
Connections · 2
- Glottochronologyconcerns
- The comparative methodconcerns
Assembled narrative · 1
Assembled from 24 blocks · 1 evidence · 34 related
- Story
- Morris Swadesh set out a method for converting the proportion of shared cognates in a fixed list of basic meanings into elapsed time since two languages diverged, assuming a universal replacement rate calibrated on documented histories. The proposal was attacked immediately and comprehensively: rates are not constant across meanings, languages or historical circumstances, and the cognacy judgements the arithmetic consumes are themselves the contested output of comparative work. Mainstream historical linguistics had largely abandoned the method by the 1970s.
- Knowledge
- The comparative method
- Glottochronology
- Glottochronology proposes to date language splits arithmetically
- Connections
- Glottochronology
- The comparative method
- Bayesian phylogenetic dating of language families
- Glottochronology proposes to date language splits arithmetically
- Language death
- Contact, borrowing and the limits of resemblance
- The regularity of sound change
- Bayesian phylogenetic dating of language families
- Sino-Tibetan
- Afroasiatic
- Proto-Indo-European
- Sir William Jones
- The Neogrammarian doctrine: sound laws admit no exception
- Glottochronology proposes to date language splits arithmetically
- Language in the Americas, and its rejection
- Evidence
- Supports the general account in this pack of the comparative method, the regularity principle, contact and borrowing, glottochronology and its critics, and the definition of a language isolate. V55 verification basis: this session had no access to any source — WebFetch was egress-blocked for every host attempted and the WebSearch budget was exhausted before authoring — so the cited work was not retrieved, and no page, volume or figure quoted from it was re-checked. No chapter or page is cited, because the book was not opened in this session; the citation identifies the work a curator should check the general account against. This is the source named in the Journey declaration.
Observed changes · 0
No public Signals are attached to this object. Signals show what changed and when it was observed — never a direction or a rank.
Actions
/atlas?object=EVT_LF_SWADESH_GLOTTOCHRONOLOGY_1952&experience=EVT_LF_SWADESH_GLOTTOCHRONOLOGY_1952